I'd like to think we're taught this as a way to show the difference between being given something you're deemed worthy enough to have, rather than taking it by force. By itself, that dichotomy seems pretty basic, especially when it comes to the people in our lives, for under no circumstances can or should they be viewed as objects.
There's been a lot of discussion in the last week, and rightly so, about the position of earning love and affection and how, in reality, it's not much different a concept than just taking it. I honestly had never considered the ramifications of that before now, but as it's something which has refused to vacate the premises of my mind, I suppose no time like the present.
I doubt I could say when I reached the conclusion that the right way to attain the love of someone else was to earn it. To suggest that any person regardless of gender, can just force another to convey such an emotion for them is ludicrous. I certainly wouldn't want it under those terms and maybe still I'm naive enough to think not a whole lot of other like-minded people would either.
*Editorial Note - In my time, I have come face-to-face with those who don't see it that way and acted based on their conclusions. I sat in rooms for five long years with rapists and predators and listened to their reasons, justifications and excuses for why they did the things they did. To this day, I'm honestly baffled that such people could ever think their actions were in any way sane or rational. I certainly can't, nor would I ever try to.
Like most teenage boys, I imagine I learned the structure of how relationships supposedly work the same way my father, grandfather and all my male ancestors did as well. The man is the one who presents himself to the woman and makes his affections known. The woman then decides if such affection shall be returned. if it is, then the relationship can begin to evolve. If not, then the man must then present themselves to a new potential mate and repeat the process.
I've often wondered, truly wondered, how stressful it has to be for women to constantly deal with the men who are interested in them. I have no context by which to base it on, so all I can do is offer complete conjecture and the willingness to engage that perspective, but I'd imagine it's got to be incredibly taxing. After all, men present themselves across the full spectrum from passive to passive-aggressive, aggressive and hostile.
I never wanted to be aggressive and I certainly didn't want to be hostile. My empathy is far too powerful for me to not think of the damage such an approach would bring to both myself and the person I was feeling the affection for. And I guess that's where the idea of earning it came from along with the mindset of being a nice guy.
Being nice wasn't ever seen as a bad thing for me. In fact, it was reinforced not only by seeing guys who were absolute dicks to everyone around them, but also in no small part by women like my grandmothers, who were both among the most amazing and caring people I've ever known. As a kid, it was the basic understanding of showing kindness to everyone, being respectful, courteous, nice. My Nana used to tell me all the time when I moved to a new town and had to start building my social circle over again, "Just be nice. Kids will like you if you're nice to them."
I took it to heart, in no small part, because I wanted to be liked. I wanted to be accepted.
Only now, some twenty-five years on, I find I've been contributing to a problem which is a whole lot bigger than me, and either through my own base ignorance or the inability to just see it, is it finally starting to sink in.
I've always thought I was going about the process from the right angle. I understood the ground rules regarding how a man is "supposed" to treat a woman and understood them well. They're common damn sense and I'm not the least bit ashamed to say I learned them in no small part by watching male figures in my life being abusive to women and concluding that I had to be the antithesis of those men.
But where I went wrong was masking myself to the notion that earning was somehow better than taking. On paper it seems that way, except relationships don't happen on paper, despite what the Screenwriters Guild of America might say to the contrary.
It's still an objectification on a more subtle scale, and as someone who's never wanted to treat people as anything other than people, the depth by which I let that shape my perspective and attitudes bothers me. It really, really bothers me. It bothers me because despite my attitude that I was never entitled to anything physical from a woman, the mindset of earning an emotional connection does establish the foundation for entitlement and I blinded myself to the manipulation that came with it.
I'm ashamed of that. I feel terrible about it. I'm angry with myself. I hate the fact that I was capable of being so disrespectful to people I genuinely cared so much about. Had I been able to recognize it sooner and do something about it, I'm willing to bet a lot of my attempts to establish relationships may have gone a lot more different than they have.
I know that the pervasive thing to do right now in the internet metaverse is to really put guys through the wringer for neither understanding or changing their learned misogynistic habits sooner, and some of it is deserved.
The relentless bombardment of media which we all consume permeated into me as well, further reinforcing the idea that feelings can be earned. To prove my point, all I had to do was type "Earn love" into Google, and that was I found the picture that accompanies this blog. It's an established, entrenched part of our cultural lexicon and has been for generations, whether we want to admit that or not.
What I hope women take away from this is that as much as they have to fight off the influences that come with their gender in how they're "supposed" to look, dress, act, think, etc., men are fighting their own gender influences as well. That's not a defense of misogyny or an excuse, but it doesn't change the fact that I've spent the majority of my life believing if I was just a nice guy, someone who practiced and showed the best qualities of who I am, that would be enough. I received positive affirmation of that from the people I looked up to, respected and trusted, both men and women who allowed this point of view to go on.
I both knowingly and willingly swallowed the Kool-Aid and only now am I understanding how poisonous it was, and I'm sorry.
Now that I finally see the full depth of how dangerous being a nice guy can be, it does make me wonder just how I am supposed to evolve from here because honestly, I'm not really sure how. Everything I know has been challenged and shaken through this discourse. It was needed and I welcome it, but now comes the question of what direction I go in, not feeling entirely sure that my instincts know which way is the right one.
I don't want to be a nice guy and I don't want to be an asshole either. I'd just like to be me and hopefully that will be enough for somebody.